(Note: The CFSC board has adopted the following commentary as an official statement.)
Since the horrific September 11 attack on the World Trade
Center, Americans have become aware in a new way of
“homeland security.” For most of us, that means security
from terror, improving airline safety, renewed military defense.
I think we now need make sure that homeland security also
includes food security. We must ensure a secure and safe
and regional food supply. We have to think in a new way
about where our food comes from, and how we can ensure
that everyone in a large yet vulnerable city like New York,
or in smaller suburban or rural communities, has enough to
eat, and access to their own cultural foods.
Americans take for granted a global food system that brings
all kinds of food from all over the world to anyone who can
afford them. Yet the real threat to U.S. food security is the
inability to produce our own food, close to our homes.
Military terrorism is in all our minds, but what happens when
terrorists are able to corrupt large food and water systems, or
destroy bridges and transportation systems on which our present
globalized and vulnerable food security depends?
We must begin thinking seriously about “food miles.” In our
present food system, the food we eat travels on average about
1200 miles. This makes our food system tremendously vulnerable
in the field, in storage, or in transit. We get a foretaste of this
threat when an area is afflicted by natural disasters such as floods,
droughts, or hurricanes. In the changed world after September 11,
that kind of threat can touch all of us.
How can we do this effectively? Every community should be able
to produce at least a third of the food required by its residents.
At present, in many cases, less than five percent is produced.
Every community should have a food system that connects producers,
processors, distributors and eaters. This would demand a rethinking
of agriculture, from industrial farming and large-scale production,
to a multiplicity of small-scale farms, with vegetables and animals,
and a revitalized marketing system.
The good news is that the seeds of this new food system are already
present. Farmers markets where citizens have access to regional food are
springing up all across the country. There are now around 1000 CSAs
(Community-Supported Agriculture) initiatives in the U.S., reaching
100,000 people. The Farm to School movement connects schools
and colleges to local farmers and brings fresh food to student
cafeterias. Urban agriculture - growing food in and around cities - is
spreading. Consumers are using their food dollars to support organic
production and the humane treatment of livestock, not factory farms.
Food Security and World Peace
Just before her untimely death, I interviewed Robyn Van En, one of the
pioneers of community-supported agriculture in the United States.
“Eating from a regional food supply,” she said, “would be a real step
toward world peace…Growing food is the common thread throughout
the world, in that everybody eats. It connects everyone across all party
lines, all ethnic and religious differences.”
Robyn spoke of the multinational food companies who control so much
of the food and extract it from starving countries to stockpile it somewhere
else until the market changes. “If every place in the whole wide world had
its own regional food supply and its own regional food security, the world
would be a very different place. It would be different if people just did
not have power over others to manipulate them with food.”
I have been thinking of these words since the terror attack of September 11.
The breeding ground of terrorism is poverty, hunger and hopelessness.
More than one billion people live on less than one dollar a day. Nearly
two billion more survive on less than two dollars a day. They are outside
the market. Biotechnology companies claim they can feed the hungry,
and ADM calls itself “Supermarket to the World.” Yet these are
empty words for the billions of poor people in the world outside the
A hungry world is indeed a dangerous place. Only when our food policies
begin with the hopes and dreams - as well as the knowledge and skills -
of the urban and rural poor of the world, will we build true food security
and this will be a huge step toward homeland security and world peace.
One of the hopeful reactions to the horrific events of September 11 has
been an awakening to our common humanity, a new solidarity, and a
longing for justice and peace. This gives me a sense of hope that real food
security and world peace may one day be possible.
Peter Mann is international coordinator for WHY (World Hunger Year)